Tomatoes in the Garden: How to Grow Them Well (and Why the Plant Type Matters More Than the Variety)

  

Every gardener eventually learns this truth:
You are not really gardening until you are growing tomatoes.

Beans forgive you. Okra tolerates you. Herbs endure you.
But tomatoes — tomatoes judge you. They reward attention and punish laziness with the speed of a summer thunderstorm.

The good news is they are not difficult. They are simply honest. Give them what they were made for and they produce with almost embarrassing generosity.

---

Determinate vs. Indeterminate (This Is the Part Most Gardeners Miss)

Before soil, fertilizer, or pruning, you must understand the plant’s personality.

Determinate Tomatoes

Often called bush tomatoes

• Grow to a fixed height (usually 3–4 ft)

• Set fruit all at once

• Stop growing after flowering

• Ripen over a 2–3 week window

These are canning tomatoes. The old kitchen-table varieties. If you want sauce, salsa, or a single large harvest, this is your plant.

They behave like a farmer: work hard, finish early, rest.

Indeterminate Tomatoes

Often called vining tomatoes

• Continue growing all season

• Produce fruit continuously

• Can reach 6–12 ft tall

• Require staking or trellising

These are sandwich tomatoes. Salad tomatoes. The daily harvest plant. One vine can feed a household from June until frost.

They behave like a preacher with no closing prayer — they simply never stop.

Practical difference:
Determinate = harvest all at once
Indeterminate = harvest all summer

Many gardening frustrations are simply the result of planting one when you expected the other.

---

Climate and Season

Tomatoes are warm-season plants.

They need:

• Warm soil (above 60°F)

• Night temperatures above 50°F

• Full sun

They do not truly grow in spring. They wait through spring. Real growth begins when nights become warm.

In the Southeast, planting usually happens after the last frost — but success really comes when the soil feels warm to your hand.

---

Soil Requirements

Tomatoes prefer soil that is:

• Loose

• Deep

• Well-drained

• Rich in organic matter

Ideal pH: 6.2–6.8

They are heavy feeders but not gluttons. Overly rich soil produces huge plants and few tomatoes — leaves you can admire, but not eat.

Before planting, mix into the bed:

• compost

• aged manure (well rotted only)

• or a balanced garden fertilizer

Avoid fresh manure. That grows foliage worthy of a jungle expedition and fruit worthy of disappointment.

Planting Properly (This Is the Secret)

Tomatoes are unusual — they can grow roots along their stems.

Instead of planting like a normal plant, do this:

1. Remove the lower leaves

2. Dig a deep hole or shallow trench

3. Bury 2/3 of the stem

4. Leave only the top cluster of leaves above ground

5. Water deeply once

Every buried section becomes roots.
More roots = stronger plant = more fruit = fewer problems.

This single step prevents half the tomato failures people blame on weather.

---

Sunlight

They require 8+ hours of direct sun.

Not bright shade. Not filtered light. Not “near the fence.”
Tomatoes are sun worshippers. Without full sun you will grow vines, not tomatoes.

---

Watering

The rule is simple:

Deep and infrequent beats shallow and frequent.

• Water deeply 2–3 times per week

• Soak the soil, not the leaves

• Morning watering is best

Inconsistent watering causes:

• blossom end rot

• cracking

• bland flavor

A tomato wants drought between drinks — just not desperation.

Mulch heavily (straw, leaves, or pine needles). It stabilizes soil moisture and temperature and cuts problems dramatically.

---

Staking, Caging, and Pruning

Indeterminate plants must be supported:

• cages

• stakes

• or trellises

Left on the ground, fruit rots and disease spreads.

You may also remove “suckers” — the shoots between the main stem and branches.
Pruning:

• improves airflow

• reduces disease

• increases fruit size

Determinate plants usually need minimal pruning.
Indeterminate plants benefit from it.

---

Fertilizing

After the first fruits appear:

Use a fertilizer lower in nitrogen and higher in phosphorus and potassium.

Too much nitrogen causes:

• huge leafy plants

• delayed fruit

• fewer tomatoes

Gardeners often unknowingly grow the healthiest leaves in the county and the fewest tomatoes on the street.

---

Common Problems (and Their Real Causes)

Blossom End Rot
Black spot on bottom of fruit
Cause: irregular watering, not lack of calcium

Cracking
Cause: heavy watering after drought

Yellow Leaves at Bottom
Often normal aging or overwatering

Flowers but No Fruit
Usually heat — above ~92°F pollen becomes sterile

Tomatoes fail less from pests than from inconsistency.

---

Harvesting

Pick when fruit is:

• fully colored

• slightly soft

• easily twists free

Vine-ripened fruit tastes better because sugars finish developing on the plant — not on a truck.

Never refrigerate fresh tomatoes. Cold ruins flavor faster than insects ever could.

An Exception

Where tomatoes often fail to ripen before frost, or without being devoured by worms and pecked by birds - commonly in the Deep South - pick them green. Let them ripen on a window sill with blossom ends down. They'll ripen soon enough. If you're impatient, fry them. A recipe is included below.  

---

Why People Love Growing Them

Because a garden tomato is not merely food — it is proof.

Proof that soil plus sun plus attention still produces abundance.
One plant, properly grown, yields pounds upon pounds of fruit. A handful of seeds becomes a table full of meals.

And once you have eaten one warm from the vine, sprinkled with a little salt, you will understand why every generation before ours insisted on keeping at least a few plants near the house. Not for novelty. For necessity.

 *****

 Classic Southern Fried Green Tomatoes

There are fancy dishes and there are permanent dishes.
Fried green tomatoes belong to the permanent kind — born from gardeners refusing to waste what the first frost, worms and birds threaten to steal. When summer ends but tomatoes still hang green and stubborn on the vine, the skillet solves the argument.

The secret is not seasoning.
The secret is firmness. You want mature green tomatoes — fully grown but not yet ripe. Hard, pale, and heavy.

---

Ingredients

• 4 large green tomatoes

• 1 cup cornmeal (preferably medium grind)

• ½ cup all purpose flour

• 1 teaspoon salt

• ½ teaspoon black pepper

• ½ teaspoon paprika (optional but traditional in many kitchens)

• 1 cup buttermilk

• 1 egg

• Bacon grease, lard, or neutral oil for frying (about ½ inch deep in skillet)

---

Preparation

1. Slice the tomatoes
   Cut into ¼- to ⅜-inch slices. Too thin and they collapse, too thick and they stay tart.

2. Salt them lightly
   Lay slices on a rack or paper towel for 10 minutes.
   This pulls a little moisture out and helps the coating stick.

3. Prepare three bowls

   • Bowl 1: flour

   • Bowl 2: buttermilk + egg (whisked together)

   • Bowl 3: cornmeal + salt + pepper + paprika

4. Dredge
   Each slice goes:
   flour → buttermilk mixture → cornmeal

   Press the cornmeal gently so it adheres. The coating should look like it belongs there, not like it was sprinkled from a distance.

---

Frying

1. Heat a cast iron skillet over medium heat

2. Add grease or oil to about ½ inch depth

3. Oil temperature: roughly 350°F (a pinch of cornmeal should sizzle immediately but not burn)

Lay slices carefully into the skillet. Do not crowd them.

Fry 3–4 minutes per side until golden brown.

Remove to a rack or paper towel.
Salt immediately while hot.

---

Serve With

• Buttermilk ranch

• Comeback sauce (mayo + ketchup + hot sauce + a little garlic)

• Or the older method: nothing but a plate and appetite

They should be:

• crisp outside

• tender inside

• slightly tart

• faintly sweet

If they taste bland, the tomatoes were immature.
If they fall apart, they were already ripening.

---

Cook’s Notes

• Bacon grease produces the best flavor. Always has.

• Do not refrigerate leftovers — reheat in a skillet or oven.

• They also make an excellent sandwich.

This dish was never restaurant food originally. It was end-of-season food — the gardener’s refusal to let a season’s labor go to waste. A green tomato, properly fried, tastes like summer arguing with autumn and refusing to surrender.

Return to GoGardenNow.com.